AHSEC Class 11 English Poetry Unit 1: "A Photograph" – Important Questions & Answers,HS 1st Year English A Photograph Important Question Answers
Studying poetry can be tricky, especially when you need to understand the meaning, themes, and emotions in a poem. "A Photograph" by Shirley Toulson is an important unit-1 of the ASSEB/AHSEC Class 11 English A Photograph Important Question Answers. To help you prepare for exams, we have put together a list of important questions and answers. In this post, you will find simple explanations, short and long-answer questions, and key points to remember. Assam Board Class 11 English Solution Whether you are revising for exams or trying to understand the poem better, this guide will be helpful.
About the Author
Shirley Toulson (1924–2018) was a British poet and writer known for her deep and reflective poetry. Her works often explore themes of time, memory, and personal experiences. She had a keen interest in history and literature, which is evident in her writing.
Short Summary of "A Photograph"
"A Photograph" by Shirley Toulson is a nostalgic poem that reflects on the passage of time and the impermanence of life. The poet describes an old photograph of her mother as a young girl, enjoying a beach trip with her cousins. She highlights how time has changed everything—her mother has grown up and passed away, while the sea remains unchanged. The poem conveys a deep sense of loss and grief as the poet reminisces about her mother’s life and the memories captured in the photograph. Through this, she emphasizes the transient nature of human life and the enduring power of memories.
POETRY UNIT-1: A PHOTOGRAPH
Short Answer Questions (1-2 Marks)
What does the cardboard refer to in the poem? (AHSEC 2019, 2023)
Answer: The cardboard refers to the old photograph of the poet’s mother, pasted on a thin piece of cardboard. It holds memories of her mother’s childhood.Who were Betty and Dolly? (AHSEC 2018)
Answer: Betty and Dolly were the two cousins of the poet’s mother who went on a sea holiday with her.What does the poet’s mother laugh at in the photograph? (AHSEC 2020, 2024)
Answer: The poet’s mother laughs at the way they were dressed up for the sea holiday, finding it funny after so many years.How does the poet describe her mother’s face in the photograph?
Answer: The poet describes her mother’s face as young, sweet, and full of innocence, reflecting her carefree childhood.What does the poet mean by the phrase, “Both wry with the labored ease of loss”? (AHSEC 2017, 2021)
Answer: The phrase means that both the poet and her mother feel the pain of losing something dear. The mother lost her carefree childhood, and the poet lost her mother.How does the photograph act as a link between the poet and her mother? (AHSEC 2022)
Answer: The photograph serves as a memory of the poet’s mother’s childhood and connects the poet emotionally to her mother, who is no longer alive.Describe the sea holiday mentioned in the poem. (AHSEC 2019)
Answer: The sea holiday was a joyful time when the poet’s mother, along with her cousins Betty and Dolly, enjoyed playing on the beach. They were carefree and happy.Why is the poet silent at the end of the poem?
Answer: The poet is silent because she is overwhelmed with emotions and the pain of losing her mother. Words cannot express her deep grief.What is the central idea of the poem A Photograph?
Answer: The poem reflects on the passage of time and the inevitability of loss. It highlights how photographs preserve memories but also remind us of the loved ones we have lost.Why does the poet call her mother’s laughter a thing of the past?
Answer: The poet calls her mother’s laughter a thing of the past because her mother is no longer alive, and the laughter now exists only as a memory.What contrasts does the poet draw between the mother’s past and present?
Answer: The poet contrasts her mother’s carefree and happy childhood with her later life, which included responsibilities and eventually her death.Why does the poet feel emotional while looking at the photograph?
Answer: The poet feels emotional because the photograph reminds her of her mother’s happy childhood and brings back the pain of her mother’s death.
Long Answer Questions (4-6 Marks)
Q1: What is the significance of the photograph in the poem? (AHSEC 2018, 2023)
The photograph in Shirley Toulson's poem serves as a powerful symbol of time, memory, and loss. It captures a moment from the past—a time when the poet's mother, as a young girl, enjoyed carefree moments with her cousins by the beach. This frozen image reminds the poet of her mother’s youthful days, emphasizing the contrast between the vibrancy of the past and the reality of the present. The photograph not only reflects the innocence and happiness of that moment but also acts as a trigger for the poet to recall her mother's life and eventual demise. For the poet, the photograph is a bittersweet relic, connecting her to her mother and highlighting the transient nature of human life.
Q2: Explain how the poet deals with the theme of loss in the poem A Photograph. (AHSEC 2020)
The theme of loss is central to Shirley Toulson's poem A Photograph. The poet expresses her deep sense of grief and longing through reflections on the photograph. The loss is twofold: the poet mourns her mother's passing and her mother's own loss of childhood, as shown by her nostalgic reaction to the photograph. The poet conveys how time inevitably leads to loss and separation. While her mother is no longer alive, the poet herself is left with memories that evoke both sadness and solace. The phrase "both wry with the laboured ease of loss" captures the enduring nature of grief and the acceptance that comes with time. Through minimal words, the poet conveys the depth of human emotions tied to loss.
Q3: Discuss how the poem portrays the fleeting nature of time. (AHSEC 2021)
In A Photograph, Shirley Toulson beautifully portrays the fleeting nature of time. The poem juxtaposes three time frames: the carefree childhood of the poet's mother, her adulthood marked by nostalgia, and the present, where both the mother and the moment captured in the photograph are gone. Time is depicted as relentless and ever-moving, leaving behind only memories. The poet reflects on how her mother once enjoyed moments that are now reduced to a photograph. Phrases like "the sea holiday was her past, mine is her laughter" emphasize how life changes over time, and everything becomes part of history. The poem subtly reminds readers that time spares no one, making human existence both beautiful and fragile.
Q4: How does Shirley Toulson depict the bond between the poet and her mother? (AHSEC 2019)
Shirley Toulson vividly depicts the bond between the poet and her mother through shared memories and emotions. The photograph is central to this bond, as it captures her mother’s childhood innocence and the poet’s love and admiration for her. The mother’s laughter at the photograph shows her fond recollection of her youth, which the poet cherishes. After her mother’s passing, the poet is left with memories that deepen her sense of loss but also reflect their connection. The phrase "silence surrounds me" suggests the void left by her mother’s absence, but the emotional weight of the poem highlights the enduring love and closeness they shared. The photograph becomes a bridge between their lives and a testament to their bond.
Q5: Analyze the poet’s feelings about the passage of time as depicted in the poem.
In A Photograph, Shirley Toulson poignantly reflects on the inevitability of time and its ability to change everything. The poet contrasts three phases: her mother’s childhood captured in the photograph, her mother’s adulthood when she nostalgically viewed the picture, and the present when her mother is no longer alive. Time is depicted as a relentless force that moves forward, leaving behind only memories. While the photograph freezes a joyful moment from the past, it also emphasizes the transient nature of life. The poet’s feelings oscillate between fondness for the memory and sorrow for the loss, underscoring how time connects and separates individuals simultaneously.
Q6: “A Photograph” captures the poet’s emotions effectively. Discuss with reference to the text.
In A Photograph, Shirley Toulson’s emotions are deeply intertwined with the themes of loss, memory, and the passage of time. The photograph serves as a poignant reminder of her mother’s carefree childhood, evoking a sense of nostalgia and love. However, the same image also highlights the reality of mortality, as the poet mourns her mother’s absence. Phrases like "the sea holiday was her past, mine is her laughter" capture how memories become all that remains of loved ones. The silence described in the poem reflects the poet’s grief, making her emotions resonate with the readers. Toulson’s ability to blend simplicity with profound depth ensures that her emotions are effectively conveyed.
Q7: Explain how the poet contrasts her present with her mother’s past in the poem.
Shirley Toulson draws a sharp contrast between her present and her mother’s past in A Photograph. The photograph captures a joyful moment from her mother’s childhood, where she stands at the beach with her cousins, carefree and full of life. In contrast, the poet’s present is marked by the loss of her mother. The poet recalls how her mother would laugh at the photograph and fondly remember that day, but now even her laughter is gone. The sea, which "appears to have changed less," symbolizes permanence, while human life is fleeting. This juxtaposition between past joy and present grief highlights the ephemeral nature of life and relationships.
Q6: How does the poet express grief for her mother in the poem?
In A Photograph, Shirley Toulson conveys her grief for her mother through subtle yet powerful expressions of loss. The poem reflects the emptiness left behind by her mother’s death, as seen in the line "There is nothing to say at all." This silence captures the inexpressible nature of her sorrow. The poet reminisces about her mother’s life, emphasizing her connection to her mother’s laughter and memories, now frozen in the photograph. The use of the phrase "laboured ease of loss" suggests that grief is both heavy and inescapable, but over time, it becomes a part of the poet’s life. Toulson’s restrained yet poignant language makes her grief relatable and profound.
Comprehension-Based Questions
Q1: What do the words “transient feet” symbolize in the poem? (AHSEC 2023)
Answer: The words "transient feet" symbolize the temporary nature of human life. It refers to the fact that while humans live and enjoy moments, their time on Earth is short and fleeting. In the poem, the poet talks about her mother’s childhood captured in the photograph, but her life, like everyone else’s, was not permanent. The phrase contrasts human life with the sea, which remains unchanged over time, highlighting the idea that human life is momentary while nature is eternal.
Q2: How does the poet describe the sea in the photograph?
Answer: The poet describes the sea in the photograph as unchanging and eternal. While the people in the picture—her mother and her cousins—have aged or passed away, the sea remains the same as it was years ago. This contrast between the ever-changing lives of humans and the permanence of nature emphasizes the fleeting nature of human existence. The sea serves as a symbol of timelessness in the poem.
Q3: How do the last two lines of the poem summarize the poet’s feelings? (AHSEC 2024)
Answer: The last two lines of the poem, "There is nothing to say at all. Its silence silences," summarize the poet's deep sense of loss and the inexpressible nature of her grief. She feels that words cannot capture the pain of losing her mother, and she is left in a state of silence. The phrase "silence silences" suggests how the absence of her mother has left her emotionally numb and speechless. These lines encapsulate the overwhelming sorrow that comes with loss.
Q4: Explain the phrase “the silence silences.”
Answer: The phrase "the silence silences" means that the poet is so overwhelmed by grief that she cannot express her feelings in words. The silence refers to the absence of her mother, and it has a profound effect on the poet, leaving her speechless. It highlights how the loss has created a void in her life, and no words can adequately describe the depth of her sorrow.
Q5: What is the significance of the mother’s smile in the photograph?
Answer: The mother’s smile in the photograph is significant because it reflects her joy and carefree nature during her childhood. It also becomes a precious memory for the poet, reminding her of her mother’s past happiness. Later in the poem, the mother’s smile is contrasted with the poet’s grief over her loss. This smile symbolizes the fleeting moments of life and the happiness that is preserved only in memories and photographs.
Likely Important Questions for Exams
Q1: What message does the poem convey about life and death?
Answer: The poem A Photograph by Shirley Toulson conveys a profound message about the transient nature of life and the inevitability of death. It juxtaposes the carefree, joyful moments of life with the reality of loss and mortality. The poet reflects on her mother’s life through the photograph, which captures her mother’s childhood happiness. However, this joy is fleeting, as her mother eventually grows old and passes away. The poem emphasizes that life is impermanent, but memories live on, often bringing both comfort and pain. It also contrasts human life, which is short-lived, with the eternal nature of elements like the sea, which remains unchanged despite the passage of time. The message is that while death is inevitable, the memories of loved ones keep their essence alive.
Q2: Explain how the photograph immortalizes the poet’s mother.
Answer: The photograph in the poem serves as a means to immortalize the poet’s mother by capturing a moment from her childhood. It freezes a joyful memory of her mother and her cousins enjoying a carefree holiday by the sea. Even though her mother has grown old and passed away, the photograph keeps that particular moment alive, making her youthful spirit timeless. The poet recalls how her mother used to look at the picture and laugh nostalgically at her own younger self, connecting the past and present. In this way, the photograph acts as a bridge between the poet’s memories and her mother’s life, ensuring that even though her mother is no longer physically present, her essence and joy remain preserved in the photograph.
Q3: What does the poet mean by “labored ease of loss”? How is this significant?
Answer: The phrase "labored ease of loss" reflects the poet’s complex emotions as she comes to terms with her mother’s death. It signifies the effort required to accept and cope with the pain of losing a loved one. While the poet has accepted the reality of her mother’s absence, the grief still lingers, making the acceptance a burden. The “ease” refers to the passage of time, which dulls the sharpness of grief, but the “labored” aspect suggests that this process is not without emotional struggle. This phrase is significant because it captures the universal experience of mourning—where time helps one move on, yet the loss always remains a part of life. It reflects the poet’s deep connection to her mother and the enduring impact of her absence.
Q4: Discuss the symbolic role of the sea in the poem.
Answer: In the poem A Photograph, the sea symbolizes timelessness and permanence, contrasting with the fleeting nature of human life. While the photograph captures a joyful moment from the poet’s mother’s childhood, the sea in the background remains unchanged over the years. The poet notes that the sea has "changed less" compared to the people in the photograph, emphasizing the enduring quality of nature. The sea also symbolizes the continuity of life, as it remains constant despite the passage of time and the inevitability of loss. By contrasting the sea’s permanence with the transient nature of human existence, the poet highlights the idea that life is fleeting but memories and nature endure.
Q5: How does Shirley Toulson emphasize the power of memories in the poem?
Answer: Shirley Toulson emphasizes the power of memories by showing how a simple photograph can preserve moments from the past and evoke strong emotions. The photograph becomes a vessel of memories, capturing a joyful moment from the poet’s mother’s childhood. This image not only immortalizes her mother’s carefree youth but also serves as a reminder of her absence after her passing. The poet reflects on how her mother used to look at the photograph with nostalgia, laughing at her younger self. Now, after her mother’s death, the photograph brings both comfort and grief to the poet, demonstrating how memories help keep loved ones alive in our minds even after they are gone.
Q6: Why does the poet feel nostalgic while looking at the photograph?
Answer: The poet feels nostalgic while looking at the photograph because it captures a joyful moment from her mother’s childhood, reminding her of the time when her mother was alive. The photograph takes the poet back to the past, where her mother, as a young girl, stood with her cousins on the beach, carefree and happy. This memory of her mother’s youth contrasts with the poet’s present reality, where her mother is no longer alive. The poet also recalls how her mother used to look at the photograph and laugh, reminiscing about her childhood. This layered nostalgia—the poet’s memory of her mother’s memories—creates a deep emotional connection and a longing for the past.
Q7: How does the poem highlight the theme of impermanence?
Answer: The poem A Photograph highlights the theme of impermanence by juxtaposing the fleeting nature of human life with the unchanging nature of the sea. The photograph captures a moment in time, freezing the poet’s mother’s childhood, but it also emphasizes that such moments are temporary. The mother grew up, aged, and eventually passed away, underscoring the transient nature of human existence. In contrast, the sea in the photograph remains unchanged, symbolizing the permanence of nature. The poet’s reflection on her mother’s death and the memories preserved in the photograph further reinforces the impermanence of life. The poem reminds readers that while life is temporary, memories and the natural world endure.
-00000-
Also Explore: AHSEC Class 11 English Notes, PYQ, Important Question Answers For Upcoming Exam